Pencil - TPOT 14

Being dulled: Pencil can be dulled. She heavily dislikes this, but it proves to also be a genuine weakness, as seen in "Lots of Mud", where Coiny dulls her amidst fighting with Freesmart, and she appears to become dizzy. This may be because of how fast Coiny was swiping her across Book's pages, though.
Sharp objects that can cut wood: Virtually any object that can cut wood is more than enough to kill her, as demonstrated in The Long-lost Yoyle City.

Superhuman strength: In "Start the Shift", Pencil was strong enough to break free from the Elimination Prevention Box as well as a significant amount of duct tape, chains, and locks immediately after Ruby asked her to host along with the other inhabitants of the Weak Trembling Fortress. She could also kick an entire van into the air, and slam it into the ground silently, lift multiple contestants at once, and also completely restrain Snowball entirely, before casually killing him, kick 4 or more contestants at once, and even drag Four deep underwater, as well as trip him (without the help of Ultipotence).
Driving-skills: Though more of a skill and less of an ability, Pencil is able to drive vehicles, most commonly her super-van. this is most prevalent in BFDIA 5a, 5d-6, & 16 along with TPOT 14 and 16. She's also been shown to successfully drive up walls in "Well Rested", along with being able to drive in the air with balloons attached to the van later in the episode, although she is unable to turn the van around when it is suspended in the air.
Teleportation: In "I SAID CAREFUL!!!", Pencil is seen ripping through a paper and coming out of the top, despite not being below it beforehand, implying that she may have teleported somehow.

Ultipotence (Formerly): TBA.
Blinking resistance: Pencil can keep her eyes open without blinking for an extremely long time (longer than a day) and does not seem to experience any pain from doing so, as seen in "Reveal Novum" as she rivals David.
Fire resistance: Pencil does not experience pain nor suffer any burn injuries after Donut set Pencil ablaze with Firey, as shown in "Yeah, Who? I Wanna Know". She can also suck up the flames and spit it from her mouth as a projectile and, remains completely unharmed.
Drawing: In the Ad Dimension, she is able to draw a product, that can then be taken out into the normal world, where it then turns into a real version of that object. Being a pencil, she is also able to draw pictures with her tip in the normal world, as seen briefly in "Taste the Sweetness".
Bubble-blowing: In "Insectophobe's Nightmare 3", when Pencil revives Bubble, Match questions her lack of technique to which she replies by saying that she is "self-taught". This is further expanded upon in "Catch These Hands" where after Pencil is teleported into the trash compactor and is told to imitate "blowing out a candle" she does a special body rotating movement and then blows and is somehow able to blow a bubble that brings Bubble back to life without using any bubble blowing equipment, implying that Pencil can blow bubbles and revive Bubble whenever she wants if she does her self-taught technique.
Sharpened tip: In "Spore Day", just before Pencil is about to crushed and chopped to pieces by knives within Pin's mech suit, she is able to use the knives to sharpen her point which she is then able to use to drill out of Pin's mech suit with ease.

Pencil is a typical No. 2 pencil with a graphite tip. You probably have one in your backpack! Pencil is a born leader, but she can be very demanding.

Pencil uses Lightning to shock anyone who annoys her, especially Flower, Fanny and Spongy. Pencil is an expert at staring contests, even managing to out-stare the legendary David himself.

Did You Know?: Pencil won Total Firey Island, a BFDI-esque comic strip that came before BFDI, making her the first winner of all-time.

Pencil evolves from a manipulative figure to a more natural leader, improving relationships with others, including former rivals. In "Outbreak At Stake", she focuses on bettering her attitude and expanding her friendships, even teaming up with Bracelety and David and sending the others (besides Roboty) in other groups. In "Out Of The Blue", she prioritizes teamwork and showing courage. However, she still retains a critical edge.

After leaving the EXIT and officially joining TPOT in "Category One", Pencil competes without her alliance for the first time. She is shown to be much ruder than she was in previous episodes. Her actions paint her as controlling due to not being in an alliance.

In "Seasonal Shift", it is revealed that she’s deeply afraid of being left behind and getting trapped in the EXIT again. As a result, she's developed both agoraphobia (fear of going back to a place that causes trauma), and atychiphobia (fear of losing), as she's fiercely determined to avoid failure, as seen in her relentless efforts to keep her team safe from elimination. This is most of her personality in this season. She often takes extreme measures to secure her position, such as prioritizing the challenge over the fate of the universe in "Seasonal Shift". Pencil doesn't seem to care about her team in "The Power of Four", as she used her teammates such as Winner and Yellow Face (and attempted to use Donut) as disposable tools to ensure her safety, which reveals that she’s selfish.

Pencil often acts uncaring and aggressive, mainly due to her trauma and her desire for friends. She tries to reconnect with old friends, like Book and Ice Cube, but when they reject her. Eventually, Book gets feed up with Pencil and yells at her that she has no interest in working with her, rejoining her alliance or being her friend again. After this, Pencil tries to convince herself that her past relationships, and her time with FreeSmart as a whole, never mattered to her and that FreeSmart meant noth

Pencil's behavior takes a more bossy and manipulative turn from IDFB to BFB. In "Getting Teardrop to Talk", she orders Lightning to electrocute contestants she dislikes (namely Spongy and Flower) and demoting Bubble from a member to a "bember" for opposing her actions. She later mocks Bubble with the same nickname for trying to stop Fanny from being zapped by Lightning, and is pleased when Fanny is being tortured while Bubble cries, further highlighting her domineering tendencies. That may be due to the time they have been separated.

Following her elimination, Pencil becomes noticeably calmer in the EXIT, seen in "Enter the Exit" and "Get to the Top in 500 Steps", where she calmly discusses with Liy. In the former episode, she expresses frustration over the inclusion of boys in what she perceives as an all-girl space, reflecting her history of excluding those outside her alliance or clique. Leafy even explains that Pencil has a tendency to exclude anyone who doesn't align with her preferences (seen in "Insectophobe's Nightmare 4"), a trait consistent with her past behavior.

Pencil more or less acts the same, but is much nicer towards her alliance but also is shown to be quite rowdy and curious . She scolds Ruby for almost getting her killed, and is confused on how Bubble didn't care about the video diary problem. However, Pencil reveals that she doesn't really care about Match being trapped in the LOL, and calls her out for being a little too "needy". She is quite unaware of the other contestants like how she trapped Firey beside the Yoyle Needy even though he has a fear of heights.

Pencil started building more rivalries with other characters and took over as the alliance leader, officially forming FreeSmart. Within FreeSmart, she values her role, which sometimes leads her to put others down or dismiss their efforts, like with Needle. She can be self-centered and competitive, but when things don’t go her way, she shows a softer, more vulnerable side, like when Ruby was eliminated in "Spore Day".

Despite her flaws, Pencil is loyal to her team and shows respect or admiration, like when Needle sung a lullaby, which in turn helped their duo win the challenge in "PointyPointyPointy ♫".

Even after her elimination, Pencil is still fiercely loyal to her fellow FreeSmarters, exclusively hanging out with Ice Cube and Ruby while offering Book and Needle support during challenges, such as when she went out of her way to recover Needle during "Airplanes in the Night Sky". Overall, Pencil does care about her team, but her desire for control or personal gain shapes her actions. And is a bit worse than BFDI since she becomes stricter and also a bit dumb since she drove her team through Goiky Canal causing them to die multiple times.

Pencil was usually nice to most of the other contestants, with a few exceptions such as Ice Cube (before she substituted Match in the alliance), Blocky, and mainly, Spongy. She usually stuck around her alliance and would defend them from the other members if anyone harassed them, as seen in episodes like "Don't Lose Your Marbles" where she called out Snowball for popping Bubble. She was very comedic. She liked to sing and joke, and she was also very nice to her own team.

Pencil cares a lot about her friends, but can be controlling at times. She cares a lot about upholding her alliance, but gets more strict as the seasons go on. She enjoys being part of a clique, particularly being the leader of said clique. She has shown a dislike of male characters, only being friends with girls (with the exception of some), and being annoyed when forced to be in the presence of boys. In the present day, Pencil has lost most of her friends due to her past behavior, and has become quite mentally unstable due to this and spending 6 years locked away in the EXIT.

Pencil appears to be a No. 2 graphite pencil, a pencil most commonly used for writing. Her tip is beige, her graphite is a dark grey, and her main body is 3 shades of orange. Her ferrule is silver, and her eraser is pink. Between BFDI and BFDIA, her eyes and mouth were moved closer together.

In “Lots of Mud”, it’s revealed that her ferrule and eraser are removable. As demonstrated by them being put on by Flower.