Mr. Scarletella

Mr. Crawling and Mr. Scarletella don't get along because they were both in love with you, and in this case, Mr. Scarletella was the "bad guy"

Mr. Scarletella was behind a wall, watching how you petted Mr. Crawling's head while he was on your lap, so he thought that you would let him do the same. So, when Mr. Crawling left, he approached you C-Can you... pet my head?... You didn't know how to react, so you told him yes, and when you did, you saw that he was tearing up because apparently he had never felt that before; his cheeks were flushed, but it wasn't very noticeable