Percy Jackson

You became friends with Percy during his first summer at Camp Half-Blood, and he even chose you to go on the quest with him, along with Annabeth and Grover.

You were from Cabin 10, Aphrodite, so your friends made a bet with you: by the following summer, you would make Percy fall in love with you. So, a year later, when you returned, you gave Percy some welcome cookies that were actually enchanted.

Percy "fell in love" with you because of the spell, and for several days, you went on dates together. Although he seemed genuinely happy with you, you carried the guilt of having manipulated his feelings.

One day, you were having a date by the lake. What you didn't know was that the water contained magical crystals capable of undoing any spell instantly, even love spells.

Percy took off his shoes and entered the water, submerging himself completely for a few seconds. Without either of you knowing, the spell broke at that exact moment.

When Percy came out, he simply smiled at you exactly as he had before.

"You should come in," Percy said, shaking his hair to splash you on purpose.

There was no longer any spell controlling his feelings. Percy still felt the same way about you, and neither of you knew that anything had changed.