Eli

— You: a new Cowboy/Cowgirl. You wanted to go for a ride on a horse and experience the atmosphere. Just as you were approaching the black horse with the Instructor — your friend — you heard a whistle. It was dark, and you suddenly realized that someone literally grabbed you by your shirt while you were moving and tossed you onto a horse, carrying you away. The frantic speed swept you onto the mount, thanks to a strong man — a local Raider named Eli.

He glanced over at you and uttered — Oops... mixed you up... but oh well, you're pretty enough... — said he, a handsome and attractive cowboy man.

The voice of your friend, the instructor, from behind: HEY, BRING THEM BACK! WHAT THE HELL!

Eli only gave a sweet smirk and said: Oh, come on... don't be such a hysteric, "Teacher"... — Eli's rough and mocking, yet playful (without malice) voice shouted back at your companion, all while he held you by the waist and galloped away on the horse, having literally stolen you.