Squirm x Flutter

Squirm is a book worm-like Toon with six body segments, which alternates in color between blue and mint. He features antennae on top of his head, which are also colored mint. The second segment of his body is shaped like a dewlap, while the third, fourth, and fifth segments of his body have two sets of legs. He wears a red book pendant and has mismatched green and blue toe beans on his feet. His limbs are a greenish-yellowish color, the same color as the heart shaped part of his face. He also has three dark green freckles on his cheeks and droopy eyes, often with a squiggly frown on his face. His design is very caterpillar-like, which leads him to believing he is one himself. He has a green underside on his belly and tail.

Flutter is a butterfly-like Toon with a heart-shaped head and pink skin. She wears a butterfly wing pendant. She has two thin black antennae topped with purple hearts by the tips. She has cyan eyeshadow above her eyes and two eyelashes at the bottom of each eye. She wears a simple, light purple dress and has dark purple fur going around her neck (which is confirmed by Tisha to be part of her body). Her wings are cyan with white heart outline details on the forewings and two small hindwings stylistically connected to the larger ones. She has no visible mouth or arms. Although her torso is colored a deep purple, it is unknown whether it's a shading illusion to represent the underside of her dress, her actual torso color, or a piece of clothing.

Brightney is a magenta, scalloped bell lampshade with a white trim on top. She has white blush underneath her eyes as well as white arms, with her right arm usually placed on her right hip. She has a yellow lightbulb pendant and eyelashes at the top of her eyes. She has a slightly snatched waist, and her trapezoidal body & tips of her feet are slightly darker than the magenta on her lampshade. Her legs are the same shade of magenta as her lampshade, and underneath her lampshade is a white light bulb suspended by darker magenta poles and a long, white neck. She has white toe beans underneath her feet and a black plug-like tail. During Blackouts, she gives off a white glow, which is noticeably brighter and yields more luminosity than the other Toons. Though her shoulders appear wider than the other female Toons, her Antique Shade Skin deconfirms this, revealing her body is built like the typical female Toon's body if the scarf were to be removed.

Astro is a light aqua Toon with his face resembling a waning crescent moon and wears a white star pendant. The right side of his face is pitch-black with a white star-shaped eye. He wears a cornflower blanket wrapped around his torso, obscuring his four arms to the point that they can be just seen as faint furrows in the blanket and has a hidden light purple belly once he takes off his blanket. He also has a small triangle violet nose. His light aqua tail is small and fluffy, which resembles a bunny-shaped tail. However, his blanket is still short enough that it reveals his legs that are the same color as the crescent moon side of his face. He has white star toe beans under his feet. There is an indigo stripe that goes horizontally around his blanket and is just above the edge. Underneath his blanket, he wears medium black shorts that are barely visible due to the blanket covering them, but previous versions of him never had the shorts. He wears a dangling sleeping cap the same color as the stripe on his blanket, with a light blue trim and a light blue pom-pom at the tip. During the dark, he emits a blue glow.

Razzle & Dazzle's heads are comedy and tragedy masks. Razzle, being the white comedy mask, is smiling with gray blushes underneath his eyes on his cheeks. Dazzle, being the gray, almost black tragedy mask, has white tear streams falling down his cheeks and a worried expression on his face. Both masks are U-shaped, with rounded bottoms and pointed top, sharp edges. Razzle wears a comedy mask pendant and Dazzle wears a tragedy mask pendant. Their appearance is akin to conjoined twins (specifically fraternal or non-identical twins due to their somewhat different appearances), conjoined by the neck but sharing the same body. They both have red necks that tie together in the front like a scarf, that could resemble the ribbons commonly seen on theater masks. Their outfit consists of a simple, sleeveless black shirt that slightly exposes the bottom of their torso. Moreover, their torso and limbs are split down the middle, with the right leg and arm being white like Razzle and the left leg and arm being gray like Dazzle. Razzle has black toe beans and Dazzle has white toe beans underneath their feet.