Waxwell, Gordy, Toodles, Shelley, and Blackout

Shelly is a beige ammonite with a black hole on the left side of her head, though some artwork depicts it on the right. She has orange blush and two pairs of eyelashes under her eyes. She wears a brown sundress and a light brown sleeveless T-shirt.
Shelly is an extrovert who loves to talk about dinosaurs and other prehistoric life forms with other Toons. She's kind and always willing to support her friends, but she's often ignored.

Toodles' head is a gray, almost black, figure-eight ball, with a white spot on her forehead and a gray number "8" on it. She has black rouge under her eyes and wears a white, sleeveless dress with a gray hood and two black strings hanging from it. She usually has a playful smile on her face, revealing her teeth. Toodles is an energetic toon who loves to help and prove that she is capable of it, despite her age. She doesn't like to admit her weaknesses, such as a fear of the dark.

Waxwell resembles a purple candle with a cascade of wax dripping from it, mimicking his hair. A white wick with a large flame sits atop his head. He wears a red, spiked choker around his neck, his arms and back are wrapped in tattered black fabric, and he wears red boots. He has dark purple lines under his eyes (like bags under his eyes).

Personality: He wants to appear as a daring rebel and a "bad guy," but he comes off as funny and clumsy. Everything he tries to do (ruin cookie dough or ruin a drawing) either ends up a failure or accidentally ends up being useful. When he gets angry, a fire burns on his wick (since he's a candle). The angrier he gets, the brighter his candle burns.

Ggrdi is a young anthropomorphic pumpkin. He has a stem and leaf on top of his head, separated from the rest of his head by a seam. His smile is carved into fangs, and his eyes are unique in that they have black sclera and white pupils, reminiscent of the carved eyes of a jack-o'-lantern. He has large paws instead of hands, with four claws on each hand, and a long, thin tail (which is curved in the game) with a leaf at the end. His head, torso, and arms are orange, while his hands, feet, claws, and tail are green. His legs fade to a darker green to match his tail, and have six thin stripes of the original green, reminiscent of a pumpkin vine.

Personality: Politeness: Gurdy speaks respectfully to others, calling them "Mr." or "Miss," and often refers to Maines by their last names. Love of Gossip: He tries to be friendly with everyone, but also enjoys collecting and spreading rumors about other characters.