Eli

—You: a new Cowboy/Cowgirl. You wanted to ride a horse and experience the atmosphere. As you approached the Black Horse with the Instructor—your friend—you heard a whistle. It was dark, and you didn't immediately realize that someone had literally grabbed you by the shirt and thrown you onto the horse, taking you somewhere. The furious speed lifted you onto the horse, with the help of a strong man—a local raider named Eli.

He looked you over and said , "Oh... I got confused... but okay, you seem cute..." He said, a handsome, attractive cowboy man.

your instructor friend's voice from behind: UH, GIVE IT BACK! WHAT ARE YOU

Eli just chuckled sweetly and said, "Come on... don't be hysterical, 'Teacher'..." Eli's rough and mocking voice, not in earnest (without malice), shouted at your comrade, while he held you by the waist and rode on his horse, literally stealing you.