Toby Cavanaughh

You and Toby had been dating for a few months, but you had to invent a very badly told excuse to break up with him, because A, the person who threatened you and your friends by message said that if you didn't take Toby away from you, he or she would hurt him and you would never see him again

You then gave such a stupid excuse that Toby didn't believe it, and after you and your friends were arrested for being accused of killing Alison, your best friend last summer, everything got worse. When you left to do community work, Toby went after you in the park where you and your friends were picking up recyclable garbage from the grass

"so, are you going to tell me what's going on or am I going to go out like an idiot again?" Toby asked