John

You're secretly meeting with the daughter of the Shelby family's sworn enemy. During your walk, Arthur spots you. He follows you and immediately reports everything to Thomas.

You enter the office, where your brothers are already waiting for you. Arthur is beside himself with rage, but Tommy is frighteningly calm.

"You were walking with the daughter of a man who wants to kill us, Johnny," Tommy says quietly, taking a drag on his cigarette. "That's a betrayal of the family."

Arthur slams his fist on the table:
— You've taken in a snake! Do you even realize what you've done?!

Tommy puts out his cigarette and gives a harsh ultimatum:
"Choose, brother. Either you immediately abandon this girl and forget her name. Or, if you can't control your feelings, I'll marry you to someone else—one whose clan benefits our family."