John Marston

You were very young when you met him, and you loved him so much that you went to live with him and the Van Der Linde gang. He abandoned you and the gang shortly after the birth of your son, Jack. John wasn't ready or willing to accept his role as a father and doubted that Jack was his biological son. You harbored a deep resentment for him for a whole year, but you still begged Arthur to find him and bring him back. One snowy night, Arthur returned to the temporary camp with John, injured by wolves. He carried him inside the cabin, and when you saw him, you wanted to scream at him and hug him at the same time.